• On MovieTome: TRANSFORMERS 2 SPOILERS!
August 22, 2008 10:43 AM PDT

How about this fight card? Dell vs. Google vs. Microsoft vs. Apple

Posted by Charles Cooper
  • Print

Despite the early kinks attending MobileMe, what's not to like about the concept? I'll include Live Mesh in the category, though Microsoft still remains in beta with the product. Synchronizing e-mail, calendars, and contacts--it's a fine idea. Unfortunately, nobody has figured it out to anyone's full satisfaction yet.

Maybe that will soon change as more companies with the means and the motivation offer cloud-based storage to consumers. One recurring rumor has Google planning an upcoming consumer service with "infinite storage" called GDrive. Take rumors for what they are worth, but given Google's (growing) cloud-centric history, it's not unreasonable to expect an announcement along those lines.

Meanwhile, another name with the bonafides is thinking about trying its hand.

Dell.

I recently caught up with Praveen Asthana, who directs storage operations at Dell. While cloud-based storage so far has had an uneven reception in the market, he says the initial consumer reluctance to store valuable digital files "out there" is receding.

"What convinces me about this is that people now are comfortable putting their photos onto the cloud," he told me. "When you read about someone's house catching on fire, what's the first thing they try and save? It's the photos and the memories."

Of course, Dell knows that it is not guaranteed to succeed where others have failed. If it were that easy, Xdrive would have turned into a money machine for AOL. Instead, the company is looking to dump the service only three years after acquiring it.

At this point, Dell is not offering more details other than to acknowledge that the idea is under consideration. Also, it is not clear whether the company would go it alone or in collaboration with another company. But Asthana still believes the change in consumer behavior is for real and that it suggests a shift that will involve the entire user food chain. "I think it will start with consumers," he says, "and then go right up to small and medium business, and then corporations."

Perhaps. After its acquisition of EqualLogic last year, Dell now sells a broad iSCSI disk array product portfolio. The thinking is that Dell would be able to successfully extend its expertise as a supplier of storage hardware into storage services. It's obviously more complicated than that, but Asthana's boss is no stranger to applying managerial lessons learned in one area to another.

Michael Dell has proved himself to be one of the savviest operators in techdom. He built a multibillion dollar business by figuring out how to sell commodity PCs, servers, and service quicker than most. Each time it stumbled, the company learned from its mistakes and moved on. Consumer-based cloud storage no doubt would be a stretch, but didn't they say the same thing at other points in Dell's history?

If the scenario comes true, it would make for one heck of a scorecard with Dell conceivably facing off against the likes of Google and Microsoft (as well Apple).But with more people participating in digital photography and digital music--and all the attendant storage demands that follow--there's ample room for companies that can get it right. Besides, Michael Dell knows how to pick his fights.

Charles is an executive editor with CNET News. He has covered technology and business for more than 25 years. A graduate of Queens College and Columbia University, Cooper began his career in journalism at the Associated Press before moving to technology coverage. Before joining CNET News, he worked at Computer & Software News, Computer Shopper, PC Week, and ZDNet. He received the Excellence in Journalism award from the Northern California branch of the Society for Professional Journalists for column writing. In addition to his blogging and podcast appearances, he is a co-host of the CNET News Daily Debrief. E-mail Charlie.
Recent posts from Coop's Corner
A penny for my thoughts. Maybe even less?
Taking a Tesla for a spin
OK, enough of the electric car feel-good story
On second thought, Microsoft's 'I'm a PC' ads are still unbelievably lame
Why Dell has its head in the clouds
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 5 comments
by paranoid.one August 22, 2008 2:00 PM PDT
Should be a great battle - the big guys have not fared well, with the notable exception of EMC acquiring Mozy. Others, like the AOL-Xdrive fiasco and HP's Upline, have tanked for a variety of reasons (Xdrive because AOL insisted they make it a media property - bad idea, and Upline because HP bought a tech that didn't really work and then put a shiny interface on it - bad plan).

There are a few companies out there doing good things - Box.net is sort of like the Xdrive of old, ElephantDrive uses Amazon S3 along with their own storage (and I heard from an exec there also uses EqualLogic - Dell relationship?), and Carbonite is sort of like Mozy for consumers.

Who else could/should be in the space? Sony? McAfee?
Reply to this comment
by juana10 August 22, 2008 2:24 PM PDT
until gdrive is here i use a tiny freeware for my backups (that has already saved me a couple of times) the way it works is that i right click a file and backup it, so usually on a daily basis i do changes to a couple of documents etc, so every time i want to backup every couple of hours, just for safety i right click that file and backup it to my mail takes a second... :) its home page is http://backup2e.com
Reply to this comment
by AppleSuxLeo August 22, 2008 10:16 PM PDT
Apple`s cloud rained out already. You can`t trust Apple with anything cloud-based. They are only adept at cranking out iPods made by Chnese prison labor.
Reply to this comment
by dude7895 August 24, 2008 9:21 PM PDT
I'm still surprised anyone actually buys those overpriced pieces of crap.
by ejeon1989 September 28, 2008 6:23 PM PDT
I don't think Dell will ever really succeed in the Cloud Computing arena because their focus is mostly on hardware (and shoddy hardware at that!). Apple showed us how NOT to get into cloud computing with MobileMe (I still prefer .mac). Microsoft and Google on the other hand, will probably come up with some interesting ideas on this area because Microsoft and Google are chiefly software companies. if I was to choose a winner, I'd pick Google just because they can do online things a little bit better than Microsoft can. However, Microsoft does have strong offerings with their Windows Live suite. i personally use Live Mail, SkyDrive, and Live Mesh (although it's still technically in beta) everyday on campus. I like Microsoft's tight integration with the Windows Live accounts over Google's right now.
Reply to this comment
advertisement

In the news now

Is video game industry recession-proof?

With strong sales numbers in recent weeks, and a perceived truism that people want inexpensive entertainment in tough times, some think video games could stay strong.



Talks to get Beatles music on iTunes stalled

Paul McCartney says the impasse is apparently between Beatles representatives and record label EMI.



Why I switched from Firefox to Chrome

I didn't set out to switch. But while using Chrome, it felt as if some friction had been removed from the Web. Now it's my default, despite its shortcomings.



Resource center from CNET News sponsors
Business. Ready.
Sony VAIO® Professional PCs.

Click Here!
A new grade in mobility demands a new kind of notebook. And Sony delivers.Tough, portable and featuring up to 7.5 hours of battery life! VAIO® Professional notebooks are built for business. Learn more.

Click Here!
Built tough for business.

Learn more about the rigorous quality testing Sony puts its notebooks through.

Protect your investment.

Find out why VAIO® tech support recently won a Laptop Editors' Choice Award, July 2008.

Long battery life.

Up to 7.5 hours of battery life! See how VAIO® PCs will keep you productive longer when on the road.

Travel light

Check out our ultraportable line-up, starting at 2.87 lbs.

PCs for every need.

Find out which VAIO® notebook is right for you.

About Coop's Corner

Charles Cooper has covered technology and business for more than 25 years. A graduate of Queens College and Columbia University, Cooper began his career in journalism at the Associated Press before moving to technology coverage. Before joining CNET News, he worked at Computer & Software News, Computer Shopper, PC Week, and ZDNet. He received the Excellence in Journalism award from the Northern California branch of the Society for Professional Journalists for column writing.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Coop's Corner topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right